Aquarium Fluidized Bed Filter Review; TMC V2, Merlin, Lifeguard

By | April 17, 2011

FSB (fluidized sand bed) Filters as a solution to increased bio load needs of large aquariums, a better, less expensive solution over large canister filters such as the Fluval FX5 or Eheim 2080, especially for freshwater planted aquariums

Revised 7/29/14

This Article/Review includes a section about Installation later in the article.

 
 

The Fluidized Sand Bed Filter is not a new concept, in fact my maintenance friends have been using these back to 1995 and even then admittedly we were far from the first to utilize the benefits of these awesome aerobic bio filters.
The most common usage is for planted aquariums, some marine aquariums, high bio load aquariums (such as “feeder fish” in aquarium stores), or as an alternative to some canister filters.
My Suggested Product Resource: TMC Premium Fluid Sand Bed Biological Aquarium Filter

Fluidized Bed Filters use fine sand kept suspended in a water flow for aerobic biological filtration. The plus is they are basically self cleaning as the sand is constantly rubbing against other grains keeping down the organic buildup.

Widespread use has been somewhat allusive, moreover, part of this is based misinformation or misunderstandings by many websites, forums, and blogs [even otherwise excellent ones].
One example of an excellent usage is for marine use, as a friend of mine set an entire marine department with these filters as the PRIMARY bio filter!
The difference is he also utilized deep sand beds, live rock and protein skimmers along with taller versions of Fluidized Sand Bed Filters to allow for anaerobic de-nitrification as well as aerobic nitrification.

My Suggested Product Resource: TMC V2 Skim Aquarium Protein Skimmer

A newer innovation that really has improved upon the use of quality fluidised aquarium filters (in this case primarily marine use) is NPX Bioplastics Nitrate & Phosphate Reducing Polymer Media.
This product is VERY efficient when used in a fluidized filter at controlling nitrates and phosphates (the TMC model is much easier to use this in I might add).
With this product, use of a Fluidized Filter in a marine reef aquarium has no boundaries at all along with already proven results in freshwater, especially planted freshwater aquariums.

My Recommended Product Resource: NPX Bioplastics Nitrate & Phosphate Reducing Polymer Media

Even without the use of NPX BioPlastics, a taller FSB Filter such as the TMC model #1500 or even #1000 can perform some de-nitrification, or in other words, nitrate removal.
Here is a quote:
“In taller fluidized-bed filters, enough aerobic bacteria cultivate in the bottom half so that as water flows past them, they remove most of the oxygen from the water, so facultative anaerobic bacteria cultivate in the top half of the sand bed where they remove nitrates.”
Quote Source: Fish Addicts; Fluidized Sand Filtration Systems

It is also noteworthy that improvements with this filter concept have been forthcoming over the years since the first models that were great in concept, but poor in design.
Unfortunately though, many spam websites such as About.com do not even list the latest generation Fluidized filters, but then my observations and those of my friends that have been in the aquarium industry for decades have seen little value to anything About.com publishes.
As an example, their article about aquarium planaria, as the information contained there in is so extremely scientifically inaccurate.
Please Reference: Aquarium Planaria or Detritus Worms?

Back to Fluidized Filters Attributes:
When properly constructed and functioning as they should (correct suspension of sand in an even churning motion), the Fluidized Filter has bio capacities unsurpassed by ANY other type of aquarium or pond filter.
To the point, the newest generation TMC V2 #600F Fluidized Filter has the bio capacity of 35 pounds of fish or other bio life, and this is the smallest model of this current generation of Fluidized Filters.
The larger model #1500F can easily surpass the overly hyped Fluval FX5/FX6 or Ehiem 2080 in pure nitrifying bio capacity [as can the smaller models].

My Suggested Product Resources:

While the new generation Fluidized filters generally cannot perform chemical filtration and only limited mechanical filtration; when compared “apples to apples” the use of these Fluidized Filters instead of the high priced and often over hyped Fluval FX5 or FX6 or Eheim 2062 /2080 should be a ‘no brainer’, especially when cost is factored in.
This said, a second filter whether a Canister, HOB, Internal, etc. that can perform these other functions AND for REDUNDANCY should be paired with a Fluidized Filter [if only as an excellent pre-filter for your Fluidised sand bed filter].

As a generalization, ANY aquarium should be set up this way with at least two filters if only for redundancy as per most aquarium professionals consulted for this article.
However many users have added products to the fluidizing chamber that can affect other aspects of aquarium filtration such as NPX Bioplastics for phosphate and nitrate removal.

For high bio load aquariums such as “monster fish tanks” with fish such as Arowana, Oscars, etc, the FSB Filter is a “Godsend” when it comes to handling this high organic load.

The picture below is from a friend’s client 220 gallon tank that uses a TMC FSB Filter Model 1500 as its primary bio filter. This particular filter has a capacity of 30 lbs of fish, etc.!!

Monster Fish Tank, High Bio Load, Fluidized Filter

 

Fluidized Sand Bed Aquarium Filters are not self powered but work well attached to an internal filter, power head/water pump (such as the SunSun HJ 1542), or canister filer.
With the power head/water pumps, the FSB filter can be placed under an aquarium, on the back, in a sump, or even in the aquarium for some models such as the TMC V2 FSB filter.
My Recommended Product Resources:

My personal preference is the use with a power head pump such as the Rio Plus 1000, 1100, or 1700 along with a Filter Max #3 [or #2 for lower flow applications].
For tanks with large amount of organic debris in the water column, the Hydro Pond #3 or #4 attached to your power head/water pump would be a good choice.

With this method versus the popular canister filter application you add redundancy if you already have a canister filter, or better if you do not have a canister filter, you free yourself from these often troublesome filter monstrosities [I know of friends in the aquarium service business who claim they get more service calls and complaints about canister filters, regardless of brand than ANY other filter type].
With the addition of a Sponge Pre-Filter, this allows for removal of debris that could potentially lower the efficiency or clog your Fluidized filter and also simply allow for added mechanical filtration that would bring many Fluidized filters to a level of bio filtration no canister filter could match!
My Recommended Product Resources:

 

A Bit of History, from an interview with friend who has spent many years in the professional aquarium design and maintenance business:

Red Sea Merlin Fluidized Sand Bed Aquarium FilterCoralife Sea Storm Fluidized Sand Bed Aquarium Filter“Our first use was with the Coralife Sea Storm & Red Sea Merlin Fluidized Filters which although these were an inferior design when compared to the later 2nd and now 3rd generation Fluid Bed Filters, these filters still impressed me and my aquarium keeping friends as to what a fluidized filter could do (as per observations at the time via measured ammonia, nitrites, nitrates).”

 

“Later we utilized the LifeGuard (Pentair) Fluidized Filters, which were a big step forward in efficiency and reliability.
The LifeGuard is also the first Fluidized Bed filter my friend used to incorporate in a partial store set up and then later after testing, the entire store!”

“In fact in tests utilizing several different canister filters such as the Via Aqua 750 (& later the similar SunSun Models), Rena Filstar 2, and Magnum, wet/dry & large canister filter only systems, which included the Ocean Clear (converted to Bio Balls, Ceramic Media) and large Eheim Filters.
The measured results showed the Fluidized Filter Systems out performed all these before mentioned filter systems by a very large margin.
This is why the next fish/aquarium store I set up was solely with a Fluidized Filter system, powered by either canister filters, internal filters, or water pump with pre-filter.”

My Recommended Product Resources:

“As for these tests; all tanks used were of similar bio load (fish by weight volume) and all tanks were well cycled and running with 0 ammonia/nitrites. We then poured in a liquefied fish food and noted the spikes in ammonia/nitrites and the time to come down from these spikes. Not only did the Fluidized systems spike very little, the spike only lasted less than a day whereas the large canister filter and wet/dry systems spiked notably higher with a few days to come back to 0 readings.”

Now, fast forward to 2011 and the 3rd generation TMC Fluidized Filter Systems; these fluidized filters have less issues with blockage or “kicking out” sand and simply put work much more reliably than the Pentair (LifeGuard) 2nd generation Fluidized Sand Filters.
The occasional leakage problems of the Lifeguard FBF are much less common with the TMC FBF.
Although actual bio filtration results are not notably better, the ease of use, versatility, and reliability make the TMC V2 Fluidized Sand Bed Filter the better choice in our experience and why this is my fluid filter of choice.

My Recommended Product Resource: TMC Fluidized Filter Systems

One example of versatility is the TMC V2 Fluidised Filter has a much more simple method of adding sand, or media such as NPX Bioplastics versus the small opening with the LifeGuard/Pentair models which are much more difficult to add additional media through.

The TMC V2 does not have as much incidence of back up as earlier models either, especially the Sea Storm and Merlin.
Sand back up is not as much problem with the 2nd generation Lifeguard Fluidized Filters (the design is still not as secure to prevent this as the TMC model), although the Lifeguard still had/has issues of poor fluidation and sand loss often due to “uneven fluidation”.


Further Information & Installation Methods:

Of most importance, especially with a “monster fish tank” that likely has a large amount of organic debris in the water column is pre-filtration.
Whether you run a canister filter that contain filter pads, sponges, etc to filter out this large debris or add a sponge pre-filter to your water pump; the use of GOOD pre-filtration is a MUST, regardless of brand [although some brands such as the Pentair clog more easily than others].

As I noted earlier, the Hydro Pond Filters will likely do the best job of pre-filtration for high organic load/debris aquariums, but other methods can be employed such as making an acrylic box, adding holes, then lining with aquarium safe sponge material or coarse poly pads to protect the water pump.
Using sheet rock or similar to hide your water pump in then back filling with pebbles or better, volcanic rock, can provide excellent pre-filtration.
What is worthy of note is that a water pump that has a lot of organic debris on the impeller or in the impeller well is a sign of poor pre-filtration and likely current or future poor performance of the fluidised sand bed filter.

A second note of importance is that most FSB Filters have a minimum and maximum sand fluidation line, this is the area where the filter is most efficient.
While being closer to the high/maximum line will yield your best results, it is not nearly as important as reaching the minimum line, so simply adjusting your FSB filter within these two lines is most important.

Next, a salient point is that your sand is going to be light initially, but as bacteria builds on the sand, it will become heavy and your fluidation level will drop.
This is nothing to worry about as long as it is above the minimum line, but if your adjustment valve is partly closed, you can can open it some more to increase the flow (assuming your pump has enough head pressure).

This brings me to the next point (which I will expand on with pictures and further information below), that is pump selection.
Make sure your flow rate is within the FSB Filter manufactures suggested minimum gph (& lph) within 1/4 of the pump or filters rated maximum head pressure. In other words a FSB Filter with a 210 gph suggested flow rated should use a pump that is rated at 210 gph or higher and a pump with a maximum rated head pressure of 6 feet and this same 210 gph flow rate should not be placed more than 1.5 feet below the water level.

This first picture to the left displays four different methods of power head installation, all utilizing a Sponge Pre-Filter, built-in sponge, or Hydro Pond Filter to “run” your Fluidized Sand Bed Filter.
Please click on this picture to enlarge

The picture displays these pump configurations (with suggested product links):

*Rio Plus 1000 with a Filter Max #2.
*Rio Plus 1100 with a Filter Max #3
*SunSun HQB-3500 Pump (this filter has a small built in sponge pre-filter)
*Rio 20 HF with a Hydro-Pond #3 (either a Hydro-Pond #3 or #4 can be substituted for a Filter Max where a high aquarium or pond bio load requires a larger pre-filter).

A TMC V2 #1500 Fluidized Filter teamed up with the Hydro-Pond #4 would provide top notch bio filtration from both the large capacity Hydro Pond #4 as well as very good medium to coarse mechanical filtration that NO CANISTER filter including the Fluval FX5 can even approach (regardless of water pump used whether the Rio 1700, or any other water pump).

With some ingenuity, one can add Purigen, Carbon, or whatever other chemical filtration media by adding to the inside of the Hydro-Pond Sponge.
Add a the NPX Bioplastics to the Fluidized Filter and for a Marine tank a Protein Skimmer and you have a first rate high capacity filter system that can easily handle a 200 gallon aquarium.

My Recommended Product Resources:

The first picture to the left displays the use of an Intake Adapter and a Return Adapter that can be a simple DIY part or purchased.
These can be helpful for some Fluidized Filter applications with a power head in the aquarium while the Fluidized filters sits below the aquarium rather on the back.
Please note that the TMC V2 Fluidized Bed Filter already includes their version of an intake adapter, however the V2 FB Filter only includes a simple return, so this return adapter pictured here provide better water control than part included.
My Recommended Product Resource: Intake & Return Adapters

The second picture to the above/left shows a simple application of a Fluidized filter connected to a SunSun Canister Filter

Product Resource:

Fluidized Sand Bed Aquarium Filter in Sump
This picture displays a TMC FSB Filter as per a of a sump system.
In this case, the aquarium owner is running the FSB filter off froma separate pump than is running the main sump system, which is suggested.
However I personally would recommend a pump with a prefilter.

 

The Set-Up Options below displays the TMC V2 Fluidized Aquarium Filter with a Power Head with Hydro Pond, and Internal Filter:
TMC Fluidized Sand Bed Aquarium Filter, Installation Options

Other Resources:

Another effective bio filter is the Sponge Filter, especially the Patented Hydro Sponge Filter.

For Further Aquarium Filter/Filtration Information, please see this article:
Aquarium Filtration; Filters

For light information for your aquarium, please see this article that is second to none:
Aquarium Lighting

Or for an accurate guide (31 years of UV-C experience went into this guide) for UV Replacement Bulb for Sterilizers, Clarifiers, & Purifiers:
UV Bulb Reference Guide

11 thoughts on “Aquarium Fluidized Bed Filter Review; TMC V2, Merlin, Lifeguard

  1. Pingback: TMC, Tropic Marine Center Aquarium Products - Aquarium Supplies, Resources

  2. alan

    hi can you please tell me can you use a fluidized filter with injected co2 and an external canister filter. or is the fluidized bed better with a power head &injected co2 many yhanks

    Reply
    1. admin Post author

      A Fluidized Filter can be used with either a canister filter or power head, however CO2 injection cannot be used in-line with the Fluidized filter.
      My preference for planted aquariums is the Fluidized filter without the canister filter since most of the newer models are exceptional bio filters

      Reply
  3. Pingback: Fluval FX 5 or Fluidized Filter | My Aquarium Opinions

  4. Pingback: Taxes and 10 Men in a Bar « C Strohmeyer's Weblog; Life, Business

  5. Pingback: On Fluidized bed filters - Filtration - Aquatic Plant Central

  6. Pingback: Diy Canister Filter- How To Take Care Of An Aquarium | Diy Canister Filter

  7. Kim Linton

    Aquarium filters are critical components of both freshwater and marine aquaria. Aquarium filters remove physical and soluble chemical waste products from aquaria, simplifying maintenance. Furthermore, aquarium filters are necessary to support life as aquaria are relatively small, closed volumes of water compared to the natural environment of most fish.

    Reply
  8. Pingback: My Aquarium Endeavors | My Endeavors

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *